Tuesday, June 17, 2014

Jesus raising Lazarus. Catacombe de Via Anapo, Rome 

Common motifs in early Christian art are food/wine miracles and the raising of Lazarus or Jairus' daughter. 


Perhaps surprisingly, some early depictions of Jesus show him using a tool of some kind when performing miracles. (Several examples can be seen here.)  

Clearly, it appears as though Jesus is using a wand to aid in the miracle and it is often interpreted as an iconographic indication that Jesus was a magician.  This can be seen in Morton Smith's Jesus the Magician (1993.) among others.  

Magic was a major part of the ancient world, but it is also important to make sure that what we have in mind when examining these images is ancient magic, and not our own contemporary understanding.  NIDB gives a good overview, and notes that the difference between magic and miracles is primarily about the social standing of the one performing the act.  It seems to have been largely an issue of insider/outsider status, as in, our magic is miraculous and yours is sorcery.  Artifacts such as documents and amulets show that magic spells had a variety of uses, such as winning a court case or a competitive event, impeding a rival or promoting success in business or love.

I don't recall when these images were first brought to my attention, but I found it quite clear that Jesus was being presented as a magician.  However, an article by Lee Jefferson (Centre College), which he has posted on academia.edu, has made me rethink this. In The Staff of Jesus in Early Christian Art  (Religion and the Arts, 14 [2010] 221–251), Jefferson notes that "there are no artistic renderings of magicians in existence from late antiquity," and that magicians of late antiquity didn't use wands. Instead,
Magicians relied upon the proper vocalization and physical execution mandated by the spell in order to procure the desired effect, not the use of an external tool like a wand. Thus, the staff in Christian art bears no association with magic.

Moses Striking the Rock. Catacomb of St. Callixtus, Rome
His argument is that we are projecting our contemporary view of magic wands that is more at home in Harry Potter stories onto a culture in which that would have been foreign.  Jefferson further notes that Jesus is not the only one in early Christian art that bears a 'wand,' but Moses and Peter do too.  This includes images of Moses bringing water from a rock with an instrument that looks more like a wand than a staff.  His conclusion, as you may have guessed from his title, is that Jesus is using a staff which connects him to Moses more than Simon Magus (Acts 8:9-24).  I find the article compelling, and pretty convincing.  



Isaac M. Alderman

Follow me on Twitter @isaacalderman
Follow Bible Junkies on Twitter @Biblejunkies
Feel free to“Like” Biblejunkies on Facebook 






3 comments:

  1. Illusionists magic illusionist magic entertainers magic entertainment magic magicians magic magician magic illusionist magic illusions magic creativity magic comedian magic experience magic communication magic comedy magic laughter magic applause magic cardistry magic mage magic miracle magic spectacle magic bespoke magic conjurers magic mind-reading magic memories magic mentalist magic hypnosis magic magic magic houdini magic genie magic theater magic variety magic stage magic prediction magic audience magic wizardry magic conjuring magic skeptic magic sorcery magic conjuror magic shuffle magic expert magic reel magic cabaret magic morale magic juggling magic mindreading magic illusion magic birthday magic children magic trickery magic prestidigitator magic mentalism magic teambuilding magic happiness magic smile magic deception magic event planners magic online meetings magic sleight of hand magic magic show magic magic shows magic virtual meeting magic virtual meetings magic card magic magic client magic computers magic software magic one-man show magic theaters magic card tricks magic showmanship magic mentalists magic showreel magic escapology magic hocus-pocus magic stage illusion magic icebreaker magic hypnotists magic.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Illusionists magic shows illusionist magic shows entertainers magic shows entertainment magic shows magic showsians magic shows magic showsian magic shows illusionist magic shows illusions magic shows creativity magic shows comedian magic shows experience magic shows communication magic shows comedy magic shows laughter magic shows applause magic shows cardistry magic shows mage magic shows miracle magic shows spectacle magic shows bespoke magic shows conjurers magic shows mind-reading magic shows memories magic shows mentalist magic shows hypnosis magic shows magic shows magic shows houdini magic shows genie magic shows theater magic shows variety magic shows stage magic shows prediction magic shows audience magic shows wizardry magic shows conjuring magic shows Jon Finch skeptic magic shows sorcery magic shows conjuror magic shows shuffle magic shows expert magic shows reel magic shows cabaret magic shows morale magic shows juggling magic shows mindreading magic shows illusion magic shows birthday magic shows children magic shows trickery magic shows prestidigitator magic shows mentalism magic shows teambuilding magic shows happiness magic shows smile magic shows deception magic shows event planners magic shows online meetings magic shows sleight of hand magic shows magic shows show magic shows magic shows magic shows magic shows virtual meeting magic shows virtual meetings magic shows card magic shows magic shows client magic shows computers magic shows software magic shows one-man show magic shows theaters magic shows card tricks magic shows showmanship magic shows mentalists magic shows showreel magic shows escapology magic shows hocus-pocus magic shows stage illusion magic shows icebreaker magic shows hypnotists magic shows.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Illusionists magic shows illusionist magic shows entertainers magic shows entertainment magic shows magic shows magic shows magic shows magic shows illusionist magic shows illusions magic shows creativity magic shows comedian magic shows experience magic shows communication magic shows comedy magic shows laughter magic shows applause magic shows cardistry magic shows mage magic shows miracle magic shows spectacle magic shows bespoke magic shows conjurers magic shows mind-reading magic shows memories magic shows mentalist magic shows hypnosis magic shows magic shows magic shows houdini magic shows genie magic shows theater magic shows variety magic shows stage magic shows prediction magic shows audience magic shows wizardry magic shows conjuring magic shows skeptic magic shows sorcery magic shows conjuror magic shows shuffle magic shows expert magic shows reel magic shows cabaret magic shows morale magic shows juggling magic shows mindreading magic shows illusion magic shows birthday magic shows children magic shows trickery magic shows prestidigitator magic shows mentalism magic shows teambuilding magic shows happiness magic shows smile magic shows deception magic shows event planners magic shows online meetings magic shows sleight of hand magic shows magic shows show magic shows magic shows magic shows magic shows virtual meeting magic shows virtual meetings magic shows card magic shows magic shows client magic shows computers magic shows software magic shows one-man show magic shows theaters magic shows card tricks magic shows showmanship magic shows mentalists magic shows showreel magic shows escapology magic shows hocus-pocus magic shows stage illusion magic shows icebreaker magic shows hypnotists magic shows. Illusionists magic shows illusionist magic shows entertainers magic shows entertainment magic shows magic shows magic shows magic shows magic shows illusionist magic shows illusions magic shows creativity magic shows comedian magic shows experience magic shows communication magic shows comedy magic shows laughter magic shows applause magic shows cardistry magic shows mage magic shows miracle magic shows spectacle magic shows bespoke magic shows conjurers magic shows mind-reading magic shows memories magic shows mentalist magic shows hypnosis magic shows magic shows magic shows houdini magic shows genie magic shows theater magic shows variety magic shows stage magic shows prediction magic shows audience magic shows wizardry magic shows conjuring magic shows skeptic magic shows sorcery magic shows conjuror magic shows shuffle magic shows expert magic shows reel magic shows cabaret magic shows morale magic shows juggling magic shows mindreading magic shows illusion magic shows birthday magic shows children magic shows trickery magic shows prestidigitator magic shows mentalism magic shows teambuilding magic shows happiness magic shows smile magic shows deception magic shows event planners magic shows online meetings magic shows sleight of hand magic shows magic shows show magic shows magic shows magic shows magic shows virtual meeting magic shows virtual meetings magic shows card magic shows magic shows client magic shows computers magic shows software magic shows one-man show magic shows theaters magic shows card tricks magic shows showmanship magic shows mentalists magic shows showreel magic shows escapology magic shows hocus-pocus magic shows stage illusion magic shows icebreaker magic shows hypnotists magic shows.

    ReplyDelete